Report says officers subjected to ‘undue’ pressure

Dudley Council officers were subjected to undue pressure, assets were sold off cheaply and anti-fraud controls were weak a new report has found.

The damning conclusions have been published after an investigation by auditors Grant Thornton into the failed sale of the Wellington Road Leisure Centre in 2024 and six other property transactions from 2021 to 2024.

Dudley Council’s leader, Cllr Patrick Harley, is identified in the report which says auditors found no evidence of fraud, bribery or unlawful conduct but there was significant weakness in governance and internal control.

Grant Thornton said: “Senior elected members, particularly the council leader, were directly involved in operational property transactions in ways that went beyond strategic oversight.

“In our view, this blurred role boundaries, created pressure on officers and weakened the control environment.

“In our view, officers faced undue pressure from the council leader that created a risk of departure from due process, and this dynamic extended through the senior officer structure — with colleagues at times placing pressure on others to comply with the council leader’s wishes rather than adhere to process and exercise independent professional judgement.”

The report goes on to say Cllr Harley was involved in negotiations which would normally be led by officers and ‘senior elected members, particularly the council leader, subjected officers to coercive and sometimes hostile behaviour — including criticism and implied threats — when officers sought to apply due process.”

Cllr Harley rejected the report’s findings as ‘flawed’ and said he was doing his job when senior officers at the time were failing.

Cllr Harley said: “None of the officers that were involved here work for Dudley Council any more, that is quite telling, they were not up to the job and projects were failing, that’s why I intervened.

“It is called living in the real world, they were on a hundred grand a year plus and not doing their jobs so the leader of the council gave them a b*****king, a leader of an organisation should be able to do that.

“They have to be grown up and deal with that, my duty is to get the best deal for the residents of Dudley.”

The report was sparked by concerns about publicity over the first Wellington Road deal, which was announced before due diligence was completed and contracts had been signed.

Cllr Harley admits he ‘jumped the gun’ in going public quickly but says protocols worked because the council got out of the deal and subsequently sold the empty leisure centre for a higher price.

The report said: “In several cases, the council was unable to demonstrate that it had achieved best consideration — that is, securing the best price reasonably obtainable for taxpayers — or followed due process.

“One transaction (the Old Glasshouse disposal) demonstrated these weaknesses. The disposal was completed at an undervalue of £55,000.”

Cllr Harley is critical of officers who were negotiating the sale and says they ‘put the knife’ into him with their account to investigators.

He said: “We had a bidder for three buildings, the old diversity office, the Glasshouse and Dudley Museum.

“Officers who have no commercial acumen thought they could get an extra £50k selling the Glasshouse to someone else.

“Had we not negotiated to sell all three we would have had two empty buildings decaying in front of us, had I not been forceful in my manner that would have failed.”

While no wrongdoing was identified, the report said: “Preventative anti-bribery and corruption arrangements were weak — particularly for high-risk activities such as property transactions and regeneration.”

Cllr Harley said: “Lessons have been learned and protocols have been tightened up.” and  added he has no intention of resigning over the findings in the report

He said: “What have I got to resign for, standing up for the residents of Dudley and holding incompetent staff to account?”

By Martyn Smith | Local Democracy Reporting Service

More from LDRS Stories

On Air Now Romantica 9:00pm - 11:00pm
Now Playing
When You're In Love With A Beautiful Woman Dr Hook Download
Recently Played

Weather

Travel News

How To Listen

Download Our Apps

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play